What are the potential pitfalls of using cryptic download links for security purposes in PHP?

Using cryptic download links for security purposes in PHP can make it difficult for users to understand the purpose of the link and may lead to confusion or distrust. Additionally, if the cryptic links are not securely generated or stored, they could potentially be guessed or intercepted by malicious actors. To mitigate these risks, it's important to ensure that the links are securely generated using strong encryption algorithms and that access to the links is properly restricted.

<?php

// Generate a cryptic download link using a secure random string
function generateDownloadLink($fileId) {
    $secretKey = 'your_secret_key_here';
    $downloadLink = 'https://example.com/download.php?file=' . $fileId . '&token=' . hash_hmac('sha256', $fileId, $secretKey);
    
    return $downloadLink;
}

// Validate the download link before allowing access to the file
function validateDownloadLink($fileId, $token) {
    $secretKey = 'your_secret_key_here';
    $expectedToken = hash_hmac('sha256', $fileId, $secretKey);
    
    if ($token === $expectedToken) {
        // Proceed with downloading the file
        echo 'File downloaded successfully!';
    } else {
        echo 'Invalid download link!';
    }
}

// Example usage
$fileId = 123;
$downloadLink = generateDownloadLink($fileId);
echo 'Download link: ' . $downloadLink . PHP_EOL;

// Simulate validating the download link
$token = 'invalid_token';
validateDownloadLink($fileId, $token);

?>